Volume 9, Number 5 · September 28, 1967

Hobbit-Forming

By Virginia Tilley

In response to Kicking the Hobbit (May 4, 1967)

To the Editors:

It seems to me that Mr. Hodgart's final fling [NYR, May 4 of "the wolf that one hears is worse than the orc that one fears" means little, as it was immediately challenged by Aragorn (a much stronger and more lordly figure than Borimer, who finally was corrupted by the Ring) with "But where the warg howls, there also the orc prowls." It is not the wolves that are bad, it is the feeling of fear and power that goes with them.

Virginia Tilley

Decatur, Illinois


 email icon Email to a friend



Search the Review
Advanced search