Sermons By a Man on a Ladder

Mephistopheles and the Androgyne

by Mircea Eliade
Sheed & Ward, 224 pp., $5.00

The Two and the One

by Mircea Eliade
Harvill Press (London), 223 pp., 30s

The Myth of the Eternal Return

by Mircea Eliade
(1949), Bollingen-Pantheon, 1954

Cosmos and History

by Mircea Eliade
Harper Torchbooks, 1959

Patterns in Comparative Religion

by Mircea Eliade
(1949), Sheed & Ward, 1958

Yoga: Immortality and Freedom

by Mircea Eliade
(1954), Bollingen-Pantheon, 1958

Birth and Rebirth

by Mircea Eliade
(1958), Harper, 1958

Rites and Symbols of Initiation

by Mircea Eliade
Harper Torchbooks, 1965

The Sacred and the Profane

by Mircea Eliade
(1957), Harper Torchbooks 1959; Harper Torchbooks, 1961

Myths, Dreams and Mysteries

by Mircea Eliade
(1957), Harper, 1960

Images and Symbols

by Mircea Eliade
(1952), Sheed & Ward, 1961

The Forge and the Crucible

by Mircea Eliade
(1956), Harper-Allenson, 1962

Shamanism: Archiac Techniques of Ecstasy

by Mircea Eliade
(1951), Bollingen-Pantheon, 1964

Merlin and his magic forest must be cut down to size before we can see the shape of the trees, but first let us examine the undergrowth. After graduating from the University of Bucharest in 1928 Mircea Eliade spent three years in Calcutta studying classical texts of Indian mysticism. His special concern was with the ascetic and ecstatic techniques whereby the would-be saint, having achieved a state of psychological dissociation, can persuade himself that he has access to the powers of the other world, being himself neither alive nor dead, neither on earth nor in heaven. All of Eliade’s subsequent writings have been concerned with this central theme, the symbolic modes through which communication is established between the sacred and the profane. His attitude is that of a Jesuit: he is scholar and believer at the same time. Eliade left Romania at the end of the war and later settled in Paris; for the past ten years he has been Professor of the History of Religion in the University of Chicago. The “history” which he pursues is not concerned with chronological sequences or the analysis of the causes and consequences of particular events, but rather with the development of human thought over vast regions of time and space. But this evolution is a very simple two-stage affair: for Eliade modern man stands to archaic man as Christianity to pre-Christianity. The cosmological ideas which characterize archaic religion are everywhere the same and may be exemplified, in Frazerian fashion, by any snippets of exotic ethnography which conveniently come to hand. Modern man is unique because the religious mythology of Judeo-Christianity is set in a matrix of chronological time. Christian time is on-going, it had a beginning and will have an end but it is non-repetitive, it is “historical.” In all other religions, time is a cyclical process. Instead of advancing boldly towards the discovery of a New Jerusalem, archaic man is content to engage in recurrent but imperfect imitation of divinely ordained archetypes fashioned by the ancestral deities in the first beginning.

ELIADE’S DIAGNOSIS may be challenged on many different grounds: bad history—there has never been a radical discordance between Christian cosmology and cyclical notions of time; bad ethnography—it is not true that the cosmologies of “archaic” man always incorporate notions of cyclical time; bad method—comparative ethnography in the style which Eliade employs, can only illustrate by example, it can never properly be used as a basis for generalization; bad psychology—Eliade takes for granted the Lévy-Bruhl fashions of his youth which assumed that ethnographic evidence reflects a pre-logical archaic mentality radically different from that of rational thought (Lévy- Bruhl himself abandoned this theory in his later years); confusion of terms—the most interesting parts of Eliade’s writings become fogged by his failure to distinguish clearly between the content of a set of symbols and its structure. It is only fair to add that in the last chapter of his latest book, Mephistopheles and the Androgyne …

This article is available to online subscribers only.
Please choose from one of the options below to access this article:

Print Premium Subscription — $94.95

Purchase a print premium subscription (20 issues per year) and also receive online access to all all content on nybooks.com.

Online Subscription — $69.00

Purchase an Online Edition subscription and receive full access to all articles published by the Review since 1963.

One-Week Access — $4.99

Purchase a trial Online Edition subscription and receive unlimited access for one week to all the content on nybooks.com.

If you already have one of these subscriptions, please be sure you are logged in to your nybooks.com account. If you subscribe to the print edition, you may also need to link your web site account to your print subscription. Click here to link your account services.