What Happened in the Fifties

November 10, 1977

Robert C. McKibben, reply by Mark Crispin Miller

E-mail Print Share
In response to:

What Happened in the Sixties? from the August 4, 1977 issue                                                  

To the Editors:

Mark Crispin Miller (“What Happened in the Sixties,” NYR, August 4) is inaccurate in citing Flannery O’Connor as an example of a Fifties’ writer whose pages are undarkened by any memory of the death camps. Her long story “The Displaced Person” (in A Good Man Is Hard to Find, 1955) makes explicit reference to the death camps (e.g., “Mrs. Shortley recalled a newsreel she had seen once of a small room piled high with bodies of dead naked people all in a heap…”) and remembers them implicitly throughout.

Robert C. McKibben

Portland, Maine

Mark Crispin Miller replies:

Mr. McKibben is quite right. The fact remains, however, that Flannery O’Connor is one of many writers of the Fifties for whom “the memory of the still vivid death camps” was not of oppressive consequence. The atomic bomb and the Final Solution did not cast a heavy pall over the whole of America throughout that decade, as Dickstein would have us believe.

Visit our Anniversary Page
Subscribe Now
Upgrade Now
Newsletter Sign Up
News of upcoming issues, contributors, special events, online features, more.