Labor’s Uphill Battle

This article is part of the Review’s series on the 2020 US elections.

On a blustery October afternoon, Joe Biden stopped in Erie, Pennsylvania, a lakeside city in a battleground county that swung to Trump in 2016, to speak to an attentive group of plumbers at a union hall. “If every investment banker in New York went on strike, nothing would change much in America,” Biden said, addressing members of United Association Local 27, who stood by their workbenches in blue shirts and face masks. “If every plumber decided to stop working, every electrician—the country comes to a halt. I mean, literally, not figuratively. Literally, it comes to a damn halt.”

A video of Biden’s comment went viral, circulated by members of the country’s resurgent labor movement, by and large a young, multiracial coalition of social media–savvy leftists—a demographic that perhaps only shares common class interests with white, middle-aged plumbers in Erie. Many of these young labor enthusiasts had been supporters of Bernie Sanders for whom Biden was not a second or even a third choice in the primaries, and who nevertheless responded to Biden’s comment with support—and calls for a general strike.

During the 2008 recession, popular support for labor unions, according to Gallup, hit an all-time low. (Historically, American opinion on unions has suffered during economic crises.) But in the last four years, enthusiasm for strikes, walkouts, sick-outs, and pickets has surged, often in unusual places. In 2018, West Virginia public school teachers, demanding higher wages and smaller classroom sizes, staged a wildcat strike that spread to a series of red states: Oklahoma, Arizona, Kentucky, and North Carolina. Amazon warehouse workers, Google and Microsoft engineers, and journalists at digital media companies have ignited their own combative movements, gaining widespread support on social media. Earlier this year, when UC Santa Cruz graduate students staged a wildcat strike for a $1,412 increase to their monthly stipend, their strike fund received nearly $300,000 on GoFundMe and support from Bernie Sanders on Twitter. Protests, organized on Twitter and Facebook, spread to nearly every single University of California campus in the state.

The new gig economy, which emerged out of Silicon Valley in the aftermath of the 2008 recession, has been a major site of labor organizing in recent years. Start-up platforms like Uber, Lyft, Instacart, Postmates, DoorDash, and Caviar—all founded in the span of four years, between 2009 and 2013— enticed millions of underemployed Americans into rideshare and food delivery jobs. These gig workers are not paid per hour, but per ride, delivery order, or task—in a poverty wage “piecework” labor model resembling the garment industry at the turn of the twentieth century, when Jewish and Italian seamstresses living in overcrowded New York City tenements were paid per piece of needlework, with no standardized minimum wage. Since 2018, thousands of gig workers have mobilized from coast to coast, staging massive multicity strikes and rallies at airports, corporate office towers, and the homes of billionaire investors. “All of the money I make goes to bills and car maintenance and gas,” an Uber driver in Orange County, California, who participated in a strike last year the day before Uber’s stock market debut, told me bitterly. “I did a ride yesterday where the rider paid $8.60, and my pay was $2.56. When you’re the driver and you see that, it makes your blood boil.”

Meanwhile, a new, progressive wing of the Democratic Party, represented by young women of color like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Ilhan Omar—whose campaigns have spotlighted the labor issues affecting their working-class constituents—has won the enthusiasm of millions of young people on Twitter, Instagram, and most recently, the livestreaming service for gamers, Twitch. Support for unions among the American public, according to Gallup, is rising again to nearly the highest it has been since the 1960s.

If the 2008 recession brought to the fore the crisis of stark inequality in the US, this year’s economic downturn due to the Covid-19 pandemic has intensified both inequality and public acknowledgement of it. The workers at the forefront of new labor movements are mobilizing as the crises rage on.

As a labor reporter, I’ve spent the pandemic holed up in my Brooklyn apartment, talking on the phone to workers who are part of this movement. Trader Joe’s cashiers, Target associates, Instacart and Uber drivers say they’ve been risking their lives at work during the pandemic for employers who deny them paid sick days and hazard pay. “The pandemic showed me the deep inequities at Whole Foods,” Alaina Mendoza, a twenty-eight-year-old Whole Foods associate in Portland, Oregon, recently told me. “When a person who worked at our store died from Covid, it lit a fire under me and my coworkers. After that, I reached out to organizers. I’m feeling really inspired by how much people want to change and how hard we’re willing to fight for it.”


A Biden presidency, infinitely better than the alternative, would still be an uphill battle for these workers. Though Biden has often leaned into his hardscrabble Scranton upbringing, critics within the labor movement see his pandering to working-class voters as more an emotional appeal than a commitment to a bold progressive agenda for the working class. Eighteen months before his speech in Erie, Biden kicked off his presidential campaign with a Philadelphia fundraiser hosted by an attorney from a union-busting law firm and a Comcast executive. In the primaries, he rejected the far-reaching social-democratic programs proposed by Sanders and Elizabeth Warren that have galvanized the young labor movement, such as the Green New Deal and cancelling all student debt.

Biden’s speech to the union plumbers in Erie does show growth in the right direction. Since Sanders dropped out of the race, Biden has taken big steps toward implementing some of the social-democratic policies, such as the Green New Deal, that he once rejected. Meanwhile, with Sanders’s advisers and his own, he’s formed task forces on the economy, health care, and climate change. Credit for much of this leftward shift should go to the workers and activists forming the new wing of the Democratic Party, rather than be attributed to genuine enthusiasm from Biden and other traditionalists within the party.

Still, whether Biden would act as a champion for the working class remains a test not only for him, but for the labor movement. In 2009, Obama and Biden disappointed labor unions when they abandoned what they claimed during campaign season was a “high-priority” initiative to pass a “card check” bill, legislation that would have vastly lowered the barriers for workers to join unions. “There’s probably going to be some compromise here,” Biden said of the bill, which never came to fruition, a month after taking office. This year Biden has promised, if elected, to pass sweeping legislation that would give gig workers minimum wage guarantees, overtime pay, health care, and the right to join unions—all of which they’re currently denied at the federal level. If Biden wins, how the labor movement responds when he inevitably resorts to compromise will depend on their willingness to engage in more of the aggressive and direct confrontation they’ve practiced during the Trump years. Only this time, their target will be the Democratic Party.

Subscribe and save 50%!

Get immediate access to the current issue and over 25,000 articles from the archives, plus the NYR App.

Already a subscriber? Sign in