In April 1982 I wrote in these pages about the case of the Russian literary critic, Konstantin Azadovsky, who was framed by the KGB on charges of drug possession [“The Azadovsky Case,” NYR, April 15, 1982, p. 35]. Some marijuana was planted in his study and then supposedly “found” by the local police, and the innocent Azadovsky was sentenced to two years of hard labor in Siberia.
That was thirteen years ago, during the Soviet era, when such abuses were routine. Since then the Soviet system has collapsed and been replaced by a Russian government that officially aspires to be democratic. The KGB was supposed to be dismantled and replaced by a new security service, the Federal Security Service, that was answerable for its actions, and the justice system was to be remodeled to reflect respect for the law. However, to judge by the ongoing case of the young Russian poet, Alina Vitukhnovskaya, now facing almost identical charges to those once levelled against Azadovsky, things haven’t changed in Russia as much as most of us had hoped.
According to the Russian writers Andrei Bitov and Tatyana Tolstaya, who brought this case to my attention at a PEN board meeting in New York, Vitukhnovskaya is an extraordinarily gifted young poet who published her first collection of poems in 1993 when she was still only twenty-one, has since published a second collection, and has exhibited an amazing maturity in all her work. Unfortunately for Vitukhnovskaya, she also wrote two articles for the magazine Novoye Vremya (New Times) about the existence of underground drug laboratories operating in Moscow; and she showed considerable familiarity with the booming youth culture of that city, which, like youth cultures everywhere, is heavily into drugs. This appears to have attracted the attention of the FSS, which first tried to tap her telephone for information, then tried to recruit her as an informer, and finally resorted to fabricating a case against her as a punishment for her refusal to cooperate.
The accusations against her are more severe than against Azadovsky, since they include trafficking as well as using, and the prospective penalties are correspondingly severe: a minimum of six years in jail. The evidence for trafficking is the sum of $20 in foreign currency, allegedly found in Vitukhnovskaya’s possession, plus an unspecified sum of rubles, while the accusation that she engaged in large-scale trading rests on the testimony of two customers (out of an alleged six or seven) who were arrested while in possession of a vial that she is supposed to have sold them. At the identification lineup where they were brought to pick her out, Vitukhnovskaya was the only person presented for inspection, and they readily identified her as the person who had sold them the vial. Needless to say, the case is hardly convincing, but that doesn’t seem to matter to the judicial authorities.
The Russian PEN Center, whose president is Andrei Bitov, offered to put up bail for Vitukhnovskaya before the case …
This article is available to online subscribers only.
Please choose from one of the options below to access this article:
Purchase a print premium subscription (20 issues per year) and also receive online access to all all content on nybooks.com.
Purchase an Online Edition subscription and receive full access to all articles published by the Review since 1963.
Purchase a trial Online Edition subscription and receive unlimited access for one week to all the content on nybooks.com.