The Other Constitutions

In a law review article published over forty years ago, Supreme Court Justice William J. Brennan argued that state constitutions are a “font of individual liberties” and that their protections, in matters like search and seizures and the right to a jury trial, often extend beyond the protections of federal law. In 51 Imperfect Solutions: States and the Making of American Constitutional Law, Jeffrey Sutton, a well-respected judge who sits on the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, endorses Brennan’s thesis and provides four examples in which state constitutional protections were or are more robust than federal ones. These examples demonstrate that the law may be best served if proponents of a new or expanded right give priority to a claim based on their state constitution, and that state judiciaries can set an example for the federal judiciary.
More 

Featured Articles





Table of contents
MLK: What We Lost
Figures like Martin Luther King, Harriet Tubman, and Rosa Parks have now become “safe” in ways they never were when they were operating at the height of their powers.
The Concrete Jungle
Evolution is still happening, sometimes briskly, and in response to the single greatest agent of environmental change on the planet: us.

Table of contents
The Autocracy App
The growing consensus is that Facebook’s power needs checking. Fewer agree on what its greatest harms are—and still fewer on what to do about them.

Table of contents

Table of contents
Aquarius Rising
Revisiting the religious dimensions of 1960s protest allows for the recovery of a forgotten and necessary part of our past.

Table of contents